Skip to main content

Table 6 Intervention effects on anthropometric indicators and nutrient intake from baseline to 3 months (n = 67)

From: A cluster randomised feasibility trial evaluating nutritional interventions in the treatment of malnutrition in care home adult residents

Outcome

SC (n = 19)

FB (n = 27)

ONS (n = 21)

SC versus FB

SC versus ONS

FB versus ONS

   

(MD)

[95 % CI]

(MD)

[95 % CI]

(MD)

[95 % CI]

Weight change (kg)

Weighed (n = 19)

Weighed (n = 27)

Weighed (n = 21)

−1.9

[−3.6, −0.23]

−2.3

[−4.3, −0.40]

−0.4

[−1.9, 1.1]

−1.5 (3.3)

0.42 (2.4)

0.82 (2.7)

      

BMI change (kg/m2)

−0.55 (1.2)

0.16 (1.0)

0.33 (1.2)

−0.7

[−1.4, −0.06]

−0.88

[−1.65, −0.11]

−0.17

[−0.79, 0.44]

MAC change (cm)

Measured(n = 13)

Measured (n = 24)

Measured(n = 18)

−0.77

[−1.7, 0.14]

−0.67

[−1.9, 0.57]

  

−1.06 (1.5)

−0.29 (1.2)

−0.39 (1.8)

      

TSF change (mm)

Measured(n = 11)

Measured (n = 19)

Measured(n = 15)

1.15

[−0.26, 2.6]

−0.77

[−2.9, 1.38]

  

0.86 (1.5)

−0.29 (2.0)

1.6 (3.6)

      

MAMC change

n = 10

n = 19

n = 16

−1.17

[−2.2, −0.14]

−0.71

[−1.44, 0.02]

  

−1.36 (0.8)

−0.18 (1.5)

−0.65 (0.9)

      

HgD change (kg)

Measured (n = 7)

Measured (n = 17)

Measured (n = 6)

0.97

[−1.9, 3.9]

1.62

[−1.34, 4.65]

  

0.16 (2.4)

−0.82 (3.4)

−1.5 (2.5)

      

Change in energy intake (kcal)

Available(n = 18)

Available (n = 27)

Available(n = 21)

−380

[−550, −226]

−479

[−697, −263]

−99

[−281, 83]

−103 (275)

277 (250)

376 (375)

      

Change in protein intake (g)

Available(n = 18)

Available (n = 27)

Available(n = 21)

−2.3

[−8.9, 4.3]

−16

[−226, −9.4]

  

0.72 (6.5)

3 (12.9)

16.7 (12.5)

      

Change in fluid intake (ml)

Available(n = 18)

Available (n = 27)

Available(n = 21)

 

Mann–Whitney

 

Mann–Whitney

  

400 (100–500)*

100 (−20 - 400)*

250 (112.5 - 250)*

 

U = 164**

 

U = 110**

  
  1. MD mean difference, SC standard care, FB food-based, ONS oral nutritional supplements, BMI body mass index, MAC mid-upper arm circumference, TSF tricep skinfold thickness, MAMC mid-arm muscle circumference, HgD handgrip dynamometer
  2. Normal data is presented as Mean change (standard deviation), otherwise is Median change (interquartile range) (indicated by *). The mean difference (MD) between each dietetic-led intervention arm (FB and ONS) and the SC arm has been calculated for normal data alongside 95 % confidence intervals (CIs), otherwise the Mann–Whitney U Test (indicated by **) has been used. Where sensitivity to change is suggested by the CI, the MD between the FB and ONS arms has then been calculated (final column)